How to Make Cowboy Coffee Without Gritty Grounds
Share
The Briefing: Declassified Series // Issue 25
Subject: cowboy coffee. Classification: widely made, widely misunderstood. Some people love it. Others call it gritty. Both camps are describing the same method, made different ways. This briefing covers what cowboy coffee is, where it came from, the exact steps, and the problem everyone runs into: grounds in the cup.
What is cowboy coffee?
Cowboy coffee is coffee brewed by putting grounds straight into hot water in an open pot, with no filter, basket or press holding them back. Hunting writer Larry Weishuhn, on the Hornady blog, passes along a definition from coffee critics: coffee made by adding grounds to boiled water, without any apparatus that keeps the grounds contained. Another source calls it the traditional name for coffee made over an open fire, likely descended from how cowboys made it out on the trail.
That is the whole idea: pot, water, grounds, heat. Everything else is technique, and technique is the difference between a clean, strong cup and a gritty one.
Where did cowboy coffee come from?
Nobody can name the first person who boiled coffee in a pot, and we are not going to invent one. What the record does support is how coffee reached cowboys in the American West.
The chuck wagon is a good starting point. According to the Buffalo Bill Center of the West, Texas rancher Charles Goodnight bought an old Army surplus Studebaker wagon in 1866 and fitted it with compartments and shelves for food, tools, water and cookware, giving cattlemen their first true chuck wagon. The same source quotes the National Ranching Heritage Center: cooks prepared three meals a day, always with hot, strong coffee.
The coffee itself was a logistics problem. The National Park Service notes that in the early years of cattle driving, coffee was hard to get on the trail because roasting the beans took time and they did not keep well. Arbuckle Coffee describes the old routine the same way: beans had to be roasted on a wood stove or in a skillet over a campfire before they could be ground and brewed.
That changed in 1865, when brothers John and Charles Arbuckle patented a process for roasting beans and coating them with an egg and sugar glaze to seal in flavor and aroma. Sold as Arbuckles' Ariosa Coffee in airtight one-pound packages, it became so common with chuck wagon cooks that many cowboys did not know another brand existed. Each package also held a stick of peppermint candy, and the cook's call of "Who wants the candy?" turned into a way to find someone to work the grinder.
One honest caveat: the nickname "the coffee that won the West" comes from popular retellings and company marketing, and we could not verify it in a primary document. The packaging, the wagon and the grinder are the parts the sources agree on.
How do you make cowboy coffee over a campfire or on a stove?
Here is a method built from the amounts and timings that the sources agree on. It works the same over a fire or on a stove burner.
- Grind coarse. Use whole bean and grind it medium-coarse to coarse. A Couple Cooks recommends medium-coarse, and general brewing references note that methods giving the grounds longer contact with hot water call for a coarser grind. Wikipedia's coffee preparation entry also describes cowboy coffee as made with coarse grounds.
- Measure. Use 2 tablespoons of ground coffee for every 8 ounces of water. Measure how much water your pot holds before you leave home.
- Heat the water. Bring the water to a rolling boil in the pot.
- Add the grounds and stir. Stir to push the grounds under the surface.
- Steep for 4 minutes. Stir again at the 2-minute mark, then let it sit 2 more minutes, for 4 minutes total.
- Settle the grounds. Pour cold water down the spout or over the top: Hornady's author uses about half a cup, and Kent Rollins uses about 1/2 to 3/4 cup in smaller pots and 1 to 1 1/2 cups in larger ones. More on that below.
- Rest, then pour slowly. Give it a couple of minutes, then pour slowly.
Pot size matters. Rollins scales the cold water to the pot, so use the smaller amount for a small pot.
What are the different ways to make cowboy coffee?
Weishuhn writes that cowboy coffee is enjoyed across the world and that there are numerous ways to prepare it properly. These are the main variations.
- Boil-first. Bring the water to a boil, take the pot off the heat for about 30 seconds, then add the grounds. Driftaway Coffee says this drops the water to around 200°F. This is the gentler route and the one we would try first.
- Grounds-first. Add grounds to cold or warm water and bring everything up together. Cowboy cook Kent Rollins adds the grounds once the water is warm, brings the pot to a full rolling boil and lets it roll for about 4 minutes, turning the heat down a touch if it threatens to boil over. He says boiling coffee this way takes out bitterness, and notes that coarser grinds need a little longer. That is his opinion and his method, and plenty of people prefer the first route.
- Eggshells or egg. Weishuhn describes a cook who added crushed shells from two eggs to the pot along with the grounds and sugar. He also notes that some people add shells because they say it neutralizes acid. We found no testing behind that acid claim, so treat it as camp tradition. The shells may help clump grounds, but that is our guess, not a sourced fact.
- Percolator contrast. A percolator is not cowboy coffee, because it cycles the boiling brew up through a basket of grounds again and again. Reference sources say percolators often expose grounds to higher temperatures and can recirculate brewed coffee, which makes overextraction easy. Cowboy coffee skips the basket and leaves the grounds in the pot.
How do you keep grounds out of cowboy coffee?
This is the part everyone asks about, and the answer is a handful of small habits, not one trick.
- Use the cold water method. After the 4-minute steep, sprinkle or pour cold water over the surface. Rollins uses 1 to 1 1/2 cups in a large pot, poured down the spout and around the edges. Hornady's author uses about half a cup in a big enamel pot. Both then wait a couple of minutes.
- Rest the pot. Time does a lot of the work. Even testers who doubted the cold water step note that waiting several minutes lets grounds drift to the bottom.
- Tap the pot. A few light taps on the side helps loose grounds sink. This is common camp practice, and we did not find a study on it.
- Wipe the spout. Rollins says grounds get caught in the spout and around the rim of smaller pots, and he dips a paper towel in water and wipes a circle around the top.
- Pour slowly. Tilt the pot gently so you do not stir the settled grounds back up. That tip is our own, not from a source.
Why does the cold water trick work?
Honest answer: nobody we found has tested it rigorously. The popular explanation is that cold water is denser, so it sinks and carries floating grounds down with it. Another is that the sudden temperature drop makes grounds clump and sink. Both sound reasonable, and neither comes from a controlled study.
Weishuhn even notes that the added water likely would not cool the contents near boiling temperature, yet he says it still makes the floating grounds sink. A Couple Cooks tested it and found that pouring cold water on top works but can leave a crunchy sip, so it is not a guarantee. The working rule: treat the cold water as one helper, pair it with a coarse grind and a real rest, and judge by what ends up in your mug.
Why does cowboy coffee matter to LACC?
Cowboy coffee is simple, and simple methods punish weak ingredients. When there is no filter to hide behind, the coffee in the pot is the whole story, which is why we start with whole bean. Grind it coarse right before the pot hits the heat, the same logic we lay out in why whole bean wins, and store what is left the way we cover in how to store coffee beans.
For a pot that takes a long steep, we would reach for Whistling Corsair, our Brazil, which has the most body in our fleet. If you like something softer, ALMIGHTY Huey from Guatemala is well rounded and V-Tail Bonanza from El Salvador is smooth and balanced. Water matters here too, so see our notes on the best water for brewing coffee. If a pot ever tastes harsh, this guide to burnt-tasting coffee explains the usual causes.
Then there is the cup. A hot pour in a thin tin mug cools fast and burns your fingers. The Legendary Widebody camp mug is a 12 oz insulated stainless mug, so it holds the heat while the last grounds settle in the pot.
Who is behind Legendary Aviation Coffee?
LACC is 100% disabled-veteran-owned and based in Rockwall, Texas. We roast light-to-medium specialty single-origin coffees named after legendary airframes, and we send 10% of profits to veteran and aviation nonprofits.
Ready to build your camp kit? Browse all of our coffees, or add a syrup to the cup.
Fly with better data.